Neeraj Singh Manhas
The detailed exploration of “Modian Consensus: The Rediscovery of Bharat” book by Dr Swadesh Singh provides a comprehensive analysis of the political and ideological shifts in India under Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s leadership. The book outlines a narrative of India’s journey towards rediscovering its civilisational identity and cultural roots, advocating a consensus around Modi’s policies and vision for the country. Dr Singh examines the Modi administration’s focus on cultural rootedness, assertive nationalism, and welfare for all, framing these as pillars of the “Modian Consensus.” He argues that this consensus marks a significant departure from previous political ideologies in India, proposing a new national ethos centered on development, inclusivity, and global stature.
The book is divided into three sections, each detailing different aspects of this consensus, from historical precedents to contemporary political strategies and future prospects. Dr Singh meticulously explores the implications of Modi’s governance, both domestically and internationally, and how it has influenced India’s policy-making and identity on the world stage.
Dr Singh’s narrative is both analytical and prescriptive, offering insights into the successes and challenges of Modi’s tenure. He provides a nuanced understanding of the political landscape, examining the interplay between ideology, governance, and public perception. The book encourages readers to consider the transformative potential of leadership that aligns with cultural and civilisational values, positioning Modi’s approach as a template for future leadership in India and potentially other nations seeking to reclaim their heritage while navigating modernity.
Section I: The Evolution of Consensus in India
The book begins by understanding consensus with an exploration of the concept of consensus, emphasising its importance in societal navigation and policy formation. It distinguishes consensus from unanimity, highlighting its role in democratic societies like India, where diverse opinions converge on broad policy goals despite disagreements.Dr Singh begins by defining consensus as an overlap of ideological positions reflecting broad policy goals, distinguishing it from unanimity. He explains how consensus allows for disagreement on core ideas while still guiding a state or society’s direction. It emphasises the dynamic nature of consensus, its evolution across different fields, and it’s inevitable weakening and transformation over time.
The book traces the roots of consensus-building efforts in India prior to its independence. It discusses the formation of a collective consciousness against colonial rule, inspired by cultural and civilisational pride. The narrative covers the evolution from the civilisational consensus, which challenged the British imposition of superiority, to the Gandhian consensus, emphasising non-violence and civil disobedience.The collective consciousness against British colonial rule, highlighting the civilisational consensus and the Gandhian Consensus. It portrays the struggle for independence as a period where consensus was built around rejecting British superiority and embracing indigenous values and leadership, setting the ideological foundation for India’s freedom movement.
However, in the Post-independence, the Nehruvian consensus took centre stage, focusing on socialism, secularism, and non-alignment. However, this consensus faced challenges over time, giving way to a secular consensus marked by instability and political fragmentation. This section delves into the transitions and the emergence of new consensus efforts against corruption and for governance reforms, setting the stage for a significant ideological shift.DrSingh critically examines the transitions in political ideologies over time, leading to the emergence of new consensus efforts that challenged corruption and sought governance reforms, setting the stage for a significant ideological shift towards the Modi era.
Section II: The Modi Era and Its Ideological Pillars
In this section Dr Singh discusses Narendra Modi’s rise to power, framed as a victory of ideological vision over political instability and corruption. It reflects on Modi’s leadership in Gujarat and his election as Prime Minister, highlighting the shift towards development-focused governance.Dr Singh explores Modi’s emphasis on India’s cultural heritage and civilizational values as foundational elements of his governance. He argues that a reconnection with cultural roots has been pivotal in shaping policies and national identity.The narrative then shifts to the theme of assertive nationalism, detailing how Modi’s government has prioritised national security and sovereignty. This approach is depicted as a departure from previous policies, with significant emphasis on self-reliance and global positioning. In the subsequent chapter he also focuses on inclusive development, this section examines the welfare schemes and initiatives launched under Modi’s leadership. He argues that these efforts aim to address the needs of the marginalised, thereby realising the principle of “Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas” (Together with all, Development for all).
Section III: Analysis and Future Directions
In this section Dr Singh defines the “Modian Consensus” as a new national ethos centered on development, cultural pride, and assertive nationalism, arguing that it represents a transformative force in Indian politics and governance.The book also acknowledges the challenges and criticisms facing the Modian Consensus, from political opposition to social movements. It discusses the resilience of the consensus in the face of these challenges and the need for adaptation and evolution.The concluding chapter reflects on the potential trajectory of India under the Modian Consensus, emphasizing the need for continuous innovation, global leadership, and adherence to India’s core values to navigate future challenges.
The book offers a comprehensive analysis of India’s political evolution, framing Modi’s policies and vision as a new consensus that seeks to integrate cultural pride, development, and assertiveness on the global stage. Dr Singh’s work is both a critical examination and a forward-looking perspective on the legacy and impact of Narendra Modi’s leadership. The book is an essential read for those interested in Indian politics, governance, and the country’s evolving role in global affairs. Dr Singh’s detailed analysis and compelling arguments make a significant contribution to the discourse on India’s political evolution in the 21stcentury, offering a thought-provoking perspective on the legacy and impact of Narendra Modi’s leadership.
(The author is the Special Advisor for South Asia at the Parley Policy Initiative, Republic of Korea)
Follow our WhatsApp channel
