The revelation that the Jammu and Kashmir Government provided misleading information to Parliament regarding saffron production highlights the critical need for accurate and scientific data collection in public administration. This episode not only undermines public trust but also threatens the credibility of the institutions responsible for guiding policies based on data. There is a huge discrepancy between the data presented by the Revenue Department and the Agriculture Department of J&K. While the Revenue Department reported a staggering 67.5 percent decline in saffron production between 2010-11 and 2023-24, Agriculture Department data revealed an 80 percent increase during the same period. This conflicting information becomes even more significant given that the year in question, 2023-24, marked a bumper crop season for saffron in Kashmir, celebrated globally for its premium quality.
The inconsistency appears to be due to the flawed methodology employed by the Revenue Department. Its reliance on single-stage Crop Cutting Experiments failed to capture the actual productivity levels, as opposed to the multi-stage CCEs recommended by scientific bodies like SKUAST-Kashmir. This difference in methodology resulted in a substantial underreporting of saffron production, inadvertently painting a grim picture of the sector’s performance. The visiting team from the Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare, which conducted an independent assessment in late October 2023, corroborated the findings of the Agriculture Department. Their evaluation further exposed the inaccuracies in the Revenue Department’s approach, emphasising the need for adopting scientific and multi-stage CCEs to estimate saffron yields accurately.
Providing misleading data to Parliament has far-reaching consequences. The Government relies on accurate information to allocate resources, frame policies, and implement measures that impact the livelihoods of farmers and the overall economy. In this case, underreported saffron production data could have led to reduced investment, inadequate policy support, and missed opportunities for marketing and promoting Kashmiri saffron on global platforms. Moreover, the misrepresentation undermines the efforts of saffron farmers who have been instrumental in revitalising this sector, especially under the National Saffron Mission. Over the past decade, initiatives such as introducing better irrigation systems, scientific farming techniques, and marketing strategies have significantly boosted saffron yields. Presenting an inaccurate picture negates these achievements and demoralises the officials involved and the farming community, who deserve due recognition and continued support.
The Financial Commissioner (Revenue)’s acknowledgement of the errors and commitment to adopting scientific methodologies in future data collection are steps in the right direction. However, this incident underscores the urgency of institutional reforms and interdepartmental coordination to prevent such lapses. This was an embarrassing lapse not to be repeated. Transparency and accountability in data collection and reporting must be prioritized. Independent audits and periodic validations by external experts, as exemplified by the Ministry of Agriculture’s intervention, can ensure the credibility of the data provided to policymakers and the public.
The saffron industry is a cornerstone of Kashmir’s economy and heritage, renowned worldwide for its distinct aroma, colour, and quality. Accurate data is pivotal for devising policies that can enhance productivity, expand market reach, and secure the livelihoods of thousands of farmers. Policymakers must leverage the latest production statistics to explore global export opportunities, promote the GI-tagged Kashmiri saffron brand, and provide farmers with incentives for adopting innovative farming techniques. A well-coordinated effort involving agricultural experts, local authorities, and Central policymakers can position saffron as a premium product on the global stage while safeguarding the interests of local farmers.
This episode serves as a stark reminder of the responsibilities of managing public data. Human errors are inevitable, but we must swiftly acknowledge and rectify them to prevent damage to institutional integrity. In a region where agriculture and allied activities form the backbone of the economy, accurate data collection is not just a technical requirement but a most important exercise for sustenance. By investing in robust systems, fostering transparency, and empowering local farmers, J&K can ensure that its saffron industry continues to flourish, benefiting both the region and the nation.
Follow our WhatsApp channel
